Share This Article:
![pennsylvania 40430 640](https://www.workerscompensation.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/pennsylvania-40430_640.png)
Powered by Simply Research
Philadelphia, PA (WorkersCompensation.com) -- A recent case from the Pennsylvania Supreme Court considered a question regarding how physicians should come to impairment rating evaluations.
Writing an "opinion in support of reversal," in Sicilia v. API Roofers Advantage Program, No. 14 MAP 2023 (Pa. 07/17/24), Justice David Wecht spelled out the case for knocking down precedent on the subject.
In Pennsylvania, an "opinion in support of" is issued when the justices split on the question at hand, which is what happened in the Sicilia case.
On the worker's claim, a physician, at the employer's assistance, issued dual impairment ratings:
(1) One that evaluated only the established work injuries.
(2) One that included additional injuries that were never found to be compensable.
A provision of Pennsylvania Worker's Compensation law requires physicians conducting impairment rating evaluations to determine the degree of impairment due to a claimant's compensable injury. Under Pennsylvania Supreme Court precedent, that approach was acceptable.
According to Justice Wecht, it was time for a change.
In 2017, Pennsylvania's Supreme Court held in Duffey v. WCAB, 152 A.3d 984 (Pa. 2017), that IRE physicians must "apply professional judgement" and evaluate not only the compensable injury but also any other injuries that the physician believes may be "fairly attributable" to that compensable injury.
In this case, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court decided that the Duffey decision was a "judicial innovation" and a "novel construction of the Act," that needed to be overturned.
"This either-or approach completely defeats the purpose of conducting IREs, which are intended in many cases to be self executing without the involvement of a WCJ," the court's majority wrote this time around.
Workers' Comp 101: In Pennsylvania, if an employer requests an IRE within 60 days of the claimant's receipt of 104 weeks of total-disability benefits and the IRE yields an impairment rating of less than 35%, then the IRE is self-executing, meaning that the claimant's disability status can be modified from total to partial without the involvement of a WCJ.
If the employer does not request the IRE within the 60-day window, it can seek to modify the claimant's benefits at any time, but it must file a modification petition and litigate the request change in disability status.
Justice Wecht concluded that Duffey made two critical mistakes:
(1) It took away the authority of WCJs to define the claimant's compensable injury.
(2) It gave physician evaluators permission to make a de novo assessment of the claimant's "compensable injury" at every IRE.
Thus, Justice Wecht called for the overturning of Duffey.
california case management case management focus claims compensability compliance compliance corner courts covid do you know the rule ethics exclusive remedy florida glossary check Healthcare health care hr homeroom iowa leadership medical medicare NCCI new jersey new york ohio opioids osha pennsylvania Safety simply research state info technology tennessee texas violence washington WDYT west virginia what do you think women's history month workers' comp 101 workers' recovery workers' compensation contact information Workplace Safety Workplace Violence
Read Also
About The Author
About The Author
-
Frank Ferreri
Frank Ferreri, M.A., J.D. covers workers' compensation legal issues. He has published books, articles, and other material on multiple areas of employment, insurance, and disability law. Frank received his master's degree from the University of South Florida and juris doctor from the University of Florida Levin College of Law. Frank encourages everyone to consider helping out the Kind Souls Foundation and Kids' Chance of America.
More by This Author
Read More
- Sep 06, 2024
- Claire Muselman
- Sep 06, 2024
- Frank Ferreri
- Sep 05, 2024
- Claire Muselman
- Sep 05, 2024
- Liz Carey
- Sep 05, 2024
- Frank Ferreri
- Sep 05, 2024
- Frank Ferreri