Share This Article:
Richmond, VA (WorkersCompensation.com) – When a worker’s foot turned painful after an on-the-job injury, it was up to a Virginia court to sort out whether it was work-related or just normal aging.
A worker experienced an injury when he fell from a tree while working for a tree trimming company. The Virginia Workers’ Compensation Commission granted the worker temporary total disability benefits and lifetime medical benefits for ankle, knee, spinal, sternal, and rib fractures.
Later, the worker sought benefits for surgery on his left foot. The worker was assigned a 15 percent partial impairment rating for his left ankle and a 12 percent permanent partial impairment rating for his left leg.
Eventually, the worker reported increasing pain in his left toe with stiffness, discoloration, and progressive deformity. He exhibited clawing of the second through fifth toes. His doctor opined that, while the worker was not having debilitating pain, his condition could worsen and require surgery. The
The doctor also opined that the worker’s foot issues were a direct result of his work injury and recommended surgery to correct them. The employer challenged the doctor’s opinion, relying on findings from an independent medical evaluation, which concluded that the work injury did not cause the worker’s problems. Instead, the IME doctor attributed the worker’s foot conditions to “common problems that many people develop as they get older.”
At a hearing, a deputy commissioner determined that a causal relationship between the worker’s foot condition and the work accident was lacking, prompting the worker to appeal to the full commission. The commission upheld the deputy’s rulings, finding that that the worker’s doctor’s opinion was “shaded by doubt.” The worker appealed to court.
In workers’ compensation, causation is a finding of fact that is typically proved by medical evidence. The treating physician’s opinion is entitled to great weight, but it’s not the only opinion courts can consider.
Did the worker show that his work injury caused his foot problems?
A. Yes. The worker’s doctor knew the worker’s health better than the IME doctor.
B. No. The IME doctor’s opinion was enough for the commission to reject the worker’s claim.
If you chose B, you agreed with the court Rankin v. Asplundh Tree Expert Co., No. 1058-21-4 (Va. Ct. App. 04/19/22, unpublished), which upheld the commission’s and deputy commissioner’s rulings in the company’s favor. The court pointed out that, even the worker’s doctor noted that the worker had good sensation in his toes, intact muscle strength, and no pain with pedal joint range of motion.
The court also highlighted the IME doctor’s opinion that the worker’s issues stemmed from “progressive bunion deformity with arthritis, and rigid contracted hammertoes.”
The court found that the IME doctor’s opinion as well as another doctor’s opinion aligned with the worker’s medical history and supported the conclusion that the injury was not work-related.
This feature does not provide legal advice.
AI california case management case management focus claims compensability compliance compliance corner courts covid do you know the rule ethics exclusive remedy florida glossary check Healthcare health care hr homeroom insurance iowa kentucky leadership medical NCCI new jersey new york ohio opioids osha pennsylvania Safety simply research state info technology texas violence WDYT west virginia what do you think women's history month workers' comp 101 workers' recovery workers' compensation contact information Workplace Safety Workplace Violence
Read Also
About The Author
About The Author
-
Frank Ferreri
Frank Ferreri, M.A., J.D. covers workers' compensation legal issues. He has published books, articles, and other material on multiple areas of employment, insurance, and disability law. Frank received his master's degree from the University of South Florida and juris doctor from the University of Florida Levin College of Law. Frank encourages everyone to consider helping out the Kind Souls Foundation and Kids' Chance of America.
More by This Author
Read More
- Nov 21, 2024
- Claire Muselman
- Nov 21, 2024
- Liz Carey
- Nov 21, 2024
- Frank Ferreri
- Nov 21, 2024
- Claire Muselman
- Nov 21, 2024
- Chris Parker
- Nov 21, 2024
- Frank Ferreri